A hazard beam on a willow (Salix sp.)

Here’s an interesting one. We have a willow (suspected Salix alba) that has a bit of a wayward limb, which has developed into a hazard beam after being bent straight (during a loading event that was probably caused by the wind, though maybe even by the limb’s own weight?). Curiously, the hazard beam is not necessarily recent as there is distinct ribbing around the wound area. I’m not sure whether one could say the region is entirely stable in terms of structural integrity, though it doesn’t appear to have split any further along the limb since the inception of the issue.

There are three courses of action here: (1) do nothing, (2) take some weight off the limb, or (3) remove the entire limb. Options 2 and 3 are perhaps more preferable, and from there it simply becomes a case of determining whether removing the entire limb would be undesirable from a long-term retention perspective (given it’d create a large wound on the trunk that a willow would probably struggle to compartmentalise, and removal would also take out a fair portion of the overall crown structure).

hazardbeamtree1
Here we can see the willow in its entirety.
hazardbeamtree2
Zooming-in onto the hazard beam, we can see how it has grown out as a very strong angle.
hazardbeamtree3
In this image, we move closer towards the wound itself. The magnitude of the split really starts to become evident.
hazardbeamtree4
Closer still, some ribbing around the area can also be observed.
Advertisements
A hazard beam on a willow (Salix sp.)

2 thoughts on “A hazard beam on a willow (Salix sp.)

    1. A good point you raise there! There’s of course the risk of the limb failing at the junction and leaving a tear-out wound where the branch tail is ripped from the trunk, though there’s also the risk of it failing along the limb itself. I suppose it then comes down to whether that managing the risk by taking part of it away is sufficient, and whether the usage of the area in which the limb resides is significant enough to warrant entire removal of the hazard in place of trying to manage its presence.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s